Rowing and running are comparable for cardio when the effort is similar. Both raise your heart rate, build aerobic fitness and can be trained at easy, steady or hard intensities. But they aren’t interchangeable. Rowing is lower impact and works the upper body. Running is weight-bearing and builds the specific fitness, tendons and bones that running demands.
What “comparable” means here
Comparable for cardio is not the same as comparable for running. Rowing can build the aerobic base that runners need, and it’s a popular cross-training tool. It won’t teach your legs the running stride or prepare you for impact, so a runner who only rows will feel the difference on race day.
Heart and lungs
Both activities raise your heart rate, and at a similar effort they can produce similar cardiovascular demands. Intensity matters more than the activity. A hard 20-minute row and a hard 20-minute run both work your heart and lungs hard. A gentle row or a gentle run both build base fitness at a lower load. Use a heart rate monitor or rate your effort on a 1 to 10 scale to compare sessions fairly.
Muscles worked
Running works mainly the legs, with the calves, quads, hamstrings and glutes doing most of the work. Rowing is a full-body movement. The legs drive most of the stroke, and the back, arms and core handle the pull and the trunk control. That is why rowing feels different to a runner, even at the same heart rate.
Impact and joints
Running is a high-impact activity. Each stride sends a load through the ankles, knees and hips, and repeated impact can lead to shin splints, stress fractures and knee pain, especially if you increase your distance too quickly.
Rowing is much lower impact because you are seated, and the foot straps hold your feet in place. That makes rowing a common choice for people who need to keep training while their joints are sore. Rowing does have its own risks. Poor technique can strain the lower back, and pulling too high can strain the shoulders, so form matters on the erg just as it does on the road.
Bone health
Running is weight-bearing, which means the bones are loaded by the impact of each stride. Weight-bearing activity is linked with bone strength, so running has a clear advantage here. Rowing puts less load through the legs’ bones, although the upper body is loaded. If bone health is a key goal, running or other weight-bearing exercise is the stronger choice.
Calories and effort
Running often burns more energy per hour than rowing, especially at higher speeds, but the gap depends on your pace, body weight and technique. A heavier person rowing hard can burn a lot, and a lighter runner at an easy jog may burn less. Don’t rely on a fixed number. Judge the work by time and effort instead.
Rowing as cross-training for runners
Rowing can help runners in three ways:
- Posterior-chain strength. The stroke works the hamstrings, glutes and back, which can balance a quad-heavy running pattern.
- Aerobic work without impact. A hard erg session builds fitness with less stress on the joints, so it can replace one run in a week.
- Recovery days. An easy, steady row can keep you moving on the day after a long run.
It can’t replace the running stride, the impact tolerance you build through running, or the specific practice of running at race pace.
Choosing between them
- Pick running if you want to race, build bone density or improve running economy.
- Pick rowing if your joints need a break, you want a full-body session, or you’re short on time and want a strong cardio session.
- Pick both if you want variety, a balanced week or a way to stay active while recovering from a running injury.
If you need an alternative to rowing for a different reason, rowing alternatives covers machines and exercises that match the erg.
Using both
A simple balanced week might include two runs, one hard erg session, one steady row, one strength session and rest days. Keep the hardest sessions apart, and increase your running volume gradually. If you are training for a race, keep your key running sessions as the priority and use rowing to top up the aerobic work.
For a practical guide on how much rowing to do, see is 10 minutes of rowing a day enough?. For interval sessions that suit both runners and rowers, see rowing interval WODs. For the wider range of erg sessions, see the rowing machine workouts guide.