The short answer
Rowing machines use four main resistance types: air, water, magnetic and hydraulic. Air and water resistance rise with how hard you pull, so the stroke responds to your effort. Magnetic resistance is set by a dial or a program and stays at that level unless you change it. Hydraulic resistance uses pistons, and it is usually the most compact and least expensive, but the stroke feels least like rowing.
Air rowers
An air rower has a fan-style flywheel in a cage. As you pull, the fan turns and moves air, so the resistance grows with your effort. A damper controls how much air reaches the fan. This is the type most often seen in gyms, and a Concept2 is the best-known example.
- Feel: responsive and dynamic. A harder pull feels harder.
- Noise: the loudest of the four, with a whooshing sound that rises with effort.
- Upkeep: low to moderate. Keep the fan area clean and the moving parts maintained.
- Best for: training with numbers, high-intensity intervals, and people who do not mind the noise.
Water rowers
A water rower has paddles that move through a tank of water. The harder you pull, the more the water resists, so the feel is dynamic, like the air rower. The water level changes how the rower feels, but you do not set the resistance with a dial.
- Feel: smooth and fluid, and many people find it closest to rowing on water.
- Noise: quieter than air. The water makes a soft splash that many people find calming.
- Upkeep: the tank needs water treatment and periodic cleaning. Follow the maker’s schedule.
- Best for: home users who want a natural feel and a quieter machine. Water rowers are often heavy, so check how you will move one.
Magnetic rowers
A magnetic rower uses magnets near a metal flywheel. You set the resistance with a dial or on a digital console, and the resistance does not rise on its own with a harder pull, unless the machine’s program changes it.
- Feel: controlled and consistent. The stroke is predictable, but it can feel less responsive than air or water.
- Noise: the quietest type. The sound is a soft hum, which suits flats and shared homes.
- Upkeep: low. There is no water and no fan to maintain.
- Best for: quiet home training and people who want precise, repeatable resistance settings.
Hydraulic rowers
A hydraulic rower uses pistons, often with a single handle. It is usually the most compact and the least expensive type. The motion is less like rowing, and the resistance is often limited. Follow the maker’s guidance on use time and on checking for leaks, because pistons can heat up.
- Feel: basic, and less fluid than the other types.
- Noise: quiet.
- Best for: small spaces, a light starting point, or a rower for occasional use.
Comparison table
| Type | Resistance rises with effort? | Noise | Upkeep | Feel |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Air | Yes | Loudest | Low to moderate | Responsive |
| Water | Yes | Quiet, soft splash | Water treatment | Smooth, natural |
| Magnetic | No, set by dial or program | Quietest | Low | Controlled |
| Hydraulic | Limited | Quiet | Checks for leaks | Basic |
Noise levels vary from one model to another, so use the table to compare types, not to predict the exact sound of a machine.
Who each type suits
- Air suits people who want measurable training and do not mind the noise. Compare the options in the Concept2 and WaterRower guide.
- Water suits people who want a natural feel and a quieter machine, with a more decorative frame.
- Magnetic suits shared homes and people who want precise, quiet settings.
- Hydraulic suits small spaces and short, occasional use.
If noise is a concern, the noise guide explains what drives sound on each type. For a connected rower with a large screen and guided classes, see the Peloton Row review.
Test before you buy
Try a few strokes on each type if you can. Feel whether the resistance rises with your effort, and whether the stroke feels smooth. Listen to the machine at a steady pace, not only at a gentle one. For how the damper and drag number work on air rowers, see the drag factor guide.