The short answer
Choose the Concept2 if you want a monitor built for measured training, a long track record, and a machine that folds for storage. Choose the WaterRower if you want a quieter, more natural water feel and a wooden frame that suits a living room. Both are well-made rowers, and both give a full-body workout. The right one depends on what keeps you rowing.
How the two work
A Concept2 RowErg uses air resistance. A fan-style flywheel sits inside a cage, and a damper lever on the side controls how much air reaches it. Pull harder and the resistance rises. The damper setting changes how much air gets in, and the drag factor guide explains the number the monitor shows.
A WaterRower uses water resistance. Paddles move through water in a tank at the front of the frame. The harder you pull, the more the water resists. The water level changes how the rower feels, but there is no damper in the same sense.
For a broader look at the four resistance types, see the resistance guide.
Feel and noise
Both rowers feel smooth when the stroke is good, and both respond to effort. The main difference is sound. An air rower makes a fan-like whoosh that gets louder as you pull harder. A water rower makes a softer splash that many people find calming. If noise matters in your home, the water rower is usually the quieter choice. The noise guide covers how to reduce sound on either machine.
Monitor and data
The Concept2 PM5 monitor shows pace, distance, stroke rate, calories and power. It also syncs to the ErgData app and to a heart rate strap. That makes it a strong choice if you train with numbers and want an online logbook.
WaterRower models use simpler monitors. The entry-level A1 shows time, distance, speed and stroke rate, and the S4 on the Original series adds more. Neither monitor is as data-led as the PM5, so check the model you are looking at.
Size, storage and design
The Concept2 is more compact and folds for storage, which helps in a small room. The WaterRower is longer and does not fold in the same way. Some WaterRower models can be stored upright, so check the current model before you measure the space.
WaterRower frames are usually made of wood, which many people find attractive. Concept2 machines have a plainer, gym-style look. Design is a matter of taste, but the footprint is a practical question.
Confirm the current dimensions on each maker’s site, because listings change and sources disagree.
Maintenance
Air rowers need occasional cleaning of the fan cage and the moving parts, and the damper setting can need checking if dust builds up. Water rowers need the tank kept clean. Many makers suggest changing the water about every six months, or sooner if it turns cloudy. Water treatment tablets are commonly used. The upkeep is small on both, but it is different.
Price and value
Both machines sit in a similar price band at the time of research, and prices change often. Check the current price, shipping and warranty on each maker’s site, and compare any refurbished options carefully. A slightly higher price can be worth it if the machine fits the room and the routine you have.
Who should buy which
Choose a Concept2 if:
- You want a monitor and logbook for structured training and testing.
- You want a machine that folds for storage.
- You do not mind the fan noise.
Choose a WaterRower if:
- Quiet operation matters, for a shared home or early mornings.
- You like the feel of water and a wooden frame.
- You do not need detailed monitor data.
If you want a connected rower with guided classes instead, see the Peloton Row review for how that type of machine compares.
Before you buy
- Measure the room, including storage height if you plan to store the machine upright.
- Test the feel if you can, at a gym or showroom, and try a few strokes.
- Check the warranty, delivery and the maintenance the maker recommends.
- Think about the monitor you need. Data-led training and a simple monitor suit different people.